guderian17 said exactly what I was thinking as I walked out before the credits rolled. Keaton stole the show and took it straight to the dumpster! I had high hopes as I usually enjoy her performances particularly in the sweet romantic roles. Mandy Moore and the male leadswere very good, but didn't get enough screen time without competing with Keatons' over the top performance. Although I didn't stay for the ending, it appeared very obvious...as though the screenplay were written by a highs school student looking for a quick assignment. Direction of Keaton appeared either non-existent or too contrived. Please, who continually carries cakes without protection down sidewalks and through stores? Uncreative, unrealistic and unbelievable.